Today, thanks to the people over at theFairy Tail Wiki, I have came up with an idea;
We should have a user review the fanfictions either posted on the wiki (like my works, for example) or a fanfic posted on a different website (most fanfics), and the user would review the latest chapter to that fanfic and give ratings for the story, fights and overall perspective.
Personally, I would like to have either admin be the one to review some fanfics, but others can do their own review as well..